From principle to practice: What it takes to make steel reuse work

By Claudia Dias, Senior Project Manager at M3 Consulting

The principle is simple: take steel from one building and give it a second life in another. The reality is considerably more complicated.

My recent experience on the newly completed 30 Duke Street St James’s development for GPE, which incorporated reclaimed steel at scale, highlighted just what it takes to make steel reuse work efficiently in practice.

Reclaimed steel does not automatically mean “reusable steel”. Before a member can be confidently allocated to new use, the condition of each section needs to be understood, for example, existing holes and connections, damage, corrosion, fire protection, geometry and dimensional tolerances.

And that assessment is not just an engineering exercise. The fabricator also needs confidence that the member can actually be worked with. Crucially, they also need assurance that the steel can be warranted. Because reclaimed steel does not carry a CE mark, rigorous testing and certification procedures become essential. At 30 Duke Street, the testing regime was developed to a standard that the fabricator advised was effectively equivalent to obtaining a CE mark, giving them the confidence to stand behind the product.

The project highlighted how the quality of information available early in the process matters enormously. The process involved inspecting and cataloguing the steel as it was recovered, creating material records, allocating sections against the recipient structure, testing and categorising the material, defabricating it and finally preparing it for fabrication.

Each step created opportunities for information to change.

Lengths were remeasured. Sections were reclassified. Damage affected whether members could be reused. Tolerances influenced where they could be allocated. What looked like a straightforward stock item could become a much more complicated piece of the design and fabrication puzzle.

The experience reinforced a few principles to carry into future steel reuse projects:

1. Define what “reusable” means at the outset.

It is better to have clear acceptance criteria and identify unsuitable material early than to spend time and money trying to save every tonne.

2. Get the measurement and information process right.

Small inaccuracies can have a disproportionate impact when sections are being matched to a specific design requirement. More robust measurement and clear, consistent data are essential.

3. Keep the process simple.

Trying to maximise reuse can sometimes create additional handling, remeasurement and redesign. The objective should be to optimise the overall process, not simply maximise the amount of steel recovered.

4. Bring the fabricator into the conversation early.

A section may be structurally suitable but difficult or uneconomic to fabricate. Engineering, recovery and fabrication decisions therefore need to be considered together.

5. Treat programme as a critical part of the reuse strategy.

Recovery, inspection, testing, defabrication, storage, fabrication and delivery all need to align. Reclaimed steel arriving too late is not a sustainable solution if it creates programme pressure elsewhere.

6. Test the commercial case properly.

The cost of reuse is not simply the cost of the steel. Inspection, testing, recovery, defabrication, handling, storage, transport, repairs and additional engineering can all form part of the equation. The comparison needs to be made on the basis of the complete process.

Perhaps the biggest takeaway is that steel reuse should not sit separately as a “sustainability initiative”.

It needs to be integrated into design, procurement, engineering, fabrication, logistics, programme and commercial decision-making from the outset and that requires good project management.

Done well, reclaimed steel can create significant environmental value. Recent projects such as 30 Duke Street for GPE, where 78% of the steel frame was reclaimed show that the opportunity is real, but only when the process is tightly coordinated from the outset. 

For me, the next generation of reuse projects will be less about asking “can we reuse this steel?” and more about asking “how do we design the project so that reuse works efficiently from day one?”.